Archive for the ‘E&O’ Category
You are currently browsing the archives for the E&O category.
You are currently browsing the archives for the E&O category.
How long can the California real estate E&O insurance market withstand the continued declines in premiums and deductibles for California residential real estate brokerages? From our perspective, not very! The anticipated change in the market is important to forecast, as we have to prepare our clients for the likely changes ahead.
Since the decline in the real estate market – dating back to 2006 – we have seen intense competition in the E&O insurance marketplace. Premium trends show year-over-year declines, along with inexplicably low deductibles. In this business cycle – referred to in insurance circles as a “soft market,” insurance companies risk not collecting enough premiums to pay for the claims their program incurs. When this happens, they eventually pull up stakes and leave you hanging in the breeze.
This much is clear; there is no way the CA real estate E&O insurance market can continue to provide the same low premium and deductible rates that we have seen over the past 4-5 years. If this trend continues, insurance companies will either incur unsustainable losses and/or they won’t be able to compete with the low cost/quality providers. Either way, they will leave the market or we all will lose.
So, what does this mean for you when deciding on which insurance program to protect your business, your reputation, and your agents? Make sure you place your E&O with a reputable insurance company (or at least make sure you are fully informed when you are entertaining a riskier program). Remember that if it seems too good to be true, it probably is. Ask your insurance broker about it: How long have they been writing in California? How many CA real estate companies do they write? Who defends me if I have a claim/law suit? How long do you see them being a player in the market? What’s not included in this policy? What’s their claims departments reputation?…etc.
Tom Byrne
Vice-President Real Estate Division
#1 – “Get ‘Er Done”
As with most New Year’s resolutions, you probably are attempting to do something you really don’t want to. But, you know if you do you will be better off for doing so. By following the below guidelines, your small investment of time will lead to the insurance peace of mind you so deserve!
#2 – Find the Right Broker
If you find the right one, your problems are solved. So, what do you look for? Trust is everything, so make sure they earn it. Every few years, test the waters to evaluate your broker’s performance. Determine what’s important for you and don’t use cost savings as the only barometer. Service, expertise, cost, choices, professionalism, referrals, credibility, locality, personality, communication skills, responsiveness…etc., are all good measuring sticks. Everyone has their own service preferences, so prioritize yours and evaluate what you have and what’s missing.
#3 – Review Your Policies
Over the course of a policy term, things change. Like your investment portfolio, your insurance portfolio needs love to. Don’t neglect it! Every year, you should review you insurance programs. How do you do this? Simply ask your broker to do it for you. Wow! That was easy. Advise them of what you are interested in reviewing and/or their suggestions. You wouldn’t want your house to burn down to be lessened in being underinsured!
#4 – Be Proactive!
Don’t procrastinate! Those that wait to submit their renewal applications at the last minute are those that are upset with having to make decisions in the 11th hour. Have your homework done in advance and you might begin to even tolerate the insurance process.
#5 – Educate Yourself
You don’t need a Master’s Degree in insurance to properly protect yourself agaisnt insurable risks, but you should know the basics – even if your broker is a “trusted advisor.” The internet is abundant with resources. Find quality blogs, newsletters, tweet feeds,…etc that best suit your lifestyle/schedule and preference. Ask around for recommendations. CSI’s dedicated social media webpage libraries a wealth of easy to access information: http://www.costelloandsons.com/socialnetworking.html
Until next time…
Tom Byrne – Vice President Real Estate Division
When looking at professional liability coverage also known as errors and omissions (E&O), it is vital to do a detailed analysis because there are differences from carrier to carrier. Curtis Pearsall, president of Pearsall Associates Inc, explains these common differences to watch for in the article, E&O Insights: Nothing Standard About Professional Liability. Here is a summary of those points.
Overall Form
The main difference on the overall form may come from claims-made basis versus occurrence form. Hutchinson Traylor Insurance defines the differences as, “Occurrence forms cover losses that happen during a given period of time (the policy term). The loss can be reported years later, but the key is when it happened. A claims-made policy covers claims made during a given period of time. The loss may have happened many years in the past, but is reported during the current policy term.” In addition, one of the differences is occurrence policy costs more than claims-made policy.
Key Terms
Let us help you review your E&O policy today!
Errors & omission insurance (E&O) is a way to safeguard your business and the professional you. This insurance provides protection from potential financial losses and suits filed against you. There are unavoidable risks that come with most jobs and the real estate industry is no different. E&O suits are not an experience most agents want to go through. Christopher J. Boggs, CPCU, ARM, ALCM writes about the general and basic “do’s and don’ts” of E&O claims, even if some are commonsense. Here is a short summary of his points:
The “Don’ts”:
The “Do’s”:
Remember these are general tips that can be customized for the real estate business. Some of the unique E&O policies include: lockbox protection, franchisor coverage, Real Estate Seller E&O coverage, and Sale of agent-owned property coverage. Furthermore, you should consider risk management in addition to E&O insurance. At CSI, we work to provide the support our clients need.
There are a lot of misnomers out there about Real Estate E&O insurance. A lot of our blog entries will surround answering questions and providing information to help clarify E&O policy myths. Here are a couple of frequently asked questions……that may receive frequently incorrect answers:
Per transaction insurance. This does NOT exist. What does exist (with a few insurers) is a payment plan on a per transaction basis. Because the policy is a claims made policy, you must keep paying for the insurance for coverage to apply. In addition, with the companies that offer per transaction policies, you typically need to report and pay monthly. You forget for a month and bam, you’ve lost coverage for all past transactions.
What is a “claim”? When does it need to be reported? The definition of a claim is determined by the E&O policy. Some policies define a claim as a demand for money or services. Others constrain the definition to written demands. Like the claim definition, claim reporting is also defined by the policy. Some policies require the “immediate” reporting of a claim while others require the reporting “as soon as practicable”.
How do claims impact premiums in future years? Your claim history will follow you for a 5 year period. The E&O insurers require 5 years of loss history to provide pricing. How these claims will impact future pricing will depend on the frequency and severity of claims. The more frequent or severe, the more likely it will negatively impact future premiums. In today’s environment, insurers are trying to push up deductibles, so rather than see a significant premium increase, a broker might see a substantial increase in the deductible.
What are some of the key issues to understand before purchasing an E&O Policy?
As we speak across California at various offices and local REALTOR® Associations, it has come to our attention that there is great confusion about differences between policies with an occurrence-based claim trigger and those with a claims-made claim trigger. Nearly all property, general liability, auto or workers’ compensation policies are written on an occurrence basis, while the vast majority of errors & omissions (E&O), directors & officers liability and employment practices liability policies are written on a claims-made coverage form.
With an occurrence policy, the policy in effect at the time of the accident or injury (or the occurrence), is the policy that will pay the claim.
Example: A REALTOR® purchases a workers’ compensation policy on May 1, 2008 (Policy A). One of the REALTOR’S® employees falls in the parking lot on the way home on Friday, April 30, 2009. The injured employee reports the injury to their broker on Monday, May 3, 2009. The workers’ compensation just happened to renew on May 1, 2009 (Policy B).
Question: Which policy will pay the claim? Answer: Policy A, the policy in effect when the injury occurred.
With a claims made policy, the policy in effect at the time of the claim is the policy that will pay the claim.
Example: A Broker purchases their first E&O policy on March 1, 2008 (Policy A). On November 20, 2008, one of the Broker’s agents sells a home. On March 1, 2009, the Broker renews their E&O policy (Policy B). On May 15, 2009, the Broker receives a lawsuit that alleges “failure to disclose” issues related to the home sold in November, 2008.
Question: Which policy will pay for the claim? Answer: Policy B, the policy in force when the claim was made.
Stay tuned……we’ll be providing more information about these differences in the future!